Fire Alarm Systems in Car Parks

Understanding Fire Detection in Car Parks

Fire alarm systems in car parks play a crucial role in ensuring the safety of both vehicles and occupants. The unique fire risks associated with car parks, including vehicle fires, fuel leaks, and electrical faults, necessitate robust and reliable detection systems.

With the increasing number of electric vehicles (EVs) in use, fire risks in covered car parks have evolved, requiring specialized detection solutions. Proper fire alarm system selection helps with early detection, reducing response times, and ensuring compliance with UK fire safety standards, such as BS 5839-1 and BS 9999.


Types of Fire Detection Systems in Car Parks

Detector Type Detection Method Best for Limitations
Smoke Detectors Detects airborne smoke particles Enclosed areas, stairwells Prone to false alarms from vehicle exhaust
Heat Detectors Detects temperature rise or high heat levels Engine bays, mechanical areas May be slow in detecting smouldering fires
Multi-Sensor Detectors Combines smoke, heat, or CO detection Reducing false alarms in general areas Higher cost than single-sensor detectors
CO (Carbon Monoxide) Detectors Detects toxic gases from incomplete combustion Underground car parks, tunnels Does not detect flames or heat
Flame Detectors Detects infrared or ultraviolet radiation from flames Open-air car parks, charging stations Only detects open flames, not smouldering fires
Aspirating Smoke Detectors (ASD) Continuously samples air for smoke particles Covered car parks, large enclosed areas High cost and maintenance
Beam Detectors Uses an optical beam to detect smoke across a large area Multi-level car parks, high ceilings Susceptible to obstructions and reflections

Choosing the Right Fire Alarm System for Car Parks

Selecting the correct fire detection technology depends on environmental factors, potential fire hazards, and the layout of the car park. Below are key considerations:

1. Smoke Detectors

  • Pros: Quick detection of smoke, good for enclosed areas.
  • Cons: Prone to false alarms due to vehicle exhaust and dust.
  • Best For: Enclosed car park levels, stairwells.
  • Avoid in: Open-air parking areas.

2. Heat Detectors

  • Pros: Effective in detecting rapid temperature rise.
  • Cons: Slow to detect smouldering fires.
  • Best For: Mechanical rooms, maintenance areas.
  • Avoid in: General parking areas where early detection is needed.

3. Multi-Sensor Detectors

  • Pros: Combines smoke, heat, or CO detection, reducing false alarms.
  • Cons: More expensive than single-sensor detectors.
  • Best For: Large covered car parks, reducing nuisance alarms.
  • Avoid in: Cost-sensitive applications.

4. Carbon Monoxide (CO) Detectors

  • Pros: Detects dangerous levels of CO from vehicle emissions.
  • Cons: Does not detect smoke or flames.
  • Best For: Underground and enclosed car parks.
  • Avoid in: Open-air car parks.

5. Flame Detectors

  • Pros: Rapid detection of open flames.
  • Cons: Does not detect smouldering fires or smoke.
  • Best For: EV charging areas, fuel station zones.
  • Avoid in: Areas where fires are likely to start as smouldering events.

6. Aspirating Smoke Detectors (ASD)

  • Pros: Highly sensitive, suitable for enclosed car parks.
  • Cons: High cost and maintenance.
  • Best For: Large multi-story car parks.
  • Avoid in: Budget-sensitive installations.

7. Beam Detectors

  • Pros: Covers large areas with minimal wiring.
  • Cons: Can be affected by obstructions or reflections.
  • Best For: High-ceiling, multi-level car parks.
  • Avoid in: Small, enclosed areas with frequent obstructions.

The Challenge of Electric Vehicles in Covered Car Parks

The growing adoption of electric vehicles (EVs) introduces new fire risks that must be considered in car park fire safety strategies. EV battery fires behave differently from traditional vehicle fires, posing unique challenges:

1. Thermal Runaway Risks

  • Lithium-ion batteries can enter thermal runaway, leading to intense fires that are difficult to extinguish.
  • Fire detection systems must be highly sensitive to heat and gas emissions to detect early warning signs.

2. Prolonged and Intense Fires

  • EV fires burn hotter and longer than petrol or diesel vehicle fires.
  • High-intensity heat detectors or aspirating smoke detection (ASD) may be required.

3. Smoke and Toxic Gas Emissions

  • EV fires release toxic gases, including hydrogen fluoride, which poses a risk to occupants.
  • Multi-sensor and CO detectors help detect harmful gases before a fire fully develops.

4. Difficulty in Fire Suppression

  • Traditional fire suppression methods may be ineffective against EV battery fires.
  • Fire alarms should integrate with fire suppression systems, such as water mist or gas suppression, where appropriate.

Final Thoughts

Fire alarm systems in car parks must be designed to address both traditional vehicle fire risks and the emerging challenges of electric vehicles. To ensure optimal safety:

Assess the unique risks associated with car parks, including EV hazards.
Select fire detectors that balance early detection with false alarm resistance.
Ensure compliance with UK fire safety regulations (BS 5839, BS 9999).
Integrate detection systems with appropriate fire suppression measures.\

By carefully selecting the correct fire alarm technology, car park operators can enhance fire safety, protect lives, and safeguard valuable assets.